Equating American Ideals to Iran’s False and Oppressive Theocracy Misrepresents the Nation’s Core Values
In a shocking moment during a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing on September 3, Virginia Democratic Senator Tim Kaine called the foundational American principle that rights come from God, not government, “extremely troubling.” His remarks, made during a confirmation hearing for Riley Barnes, nominee for Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, have ignited a firestorm, with critics questioning whether Kaine has overlooked the clear language of the Declaration of Independence and the philosophical underpinnings of the U.S. Constitution. Kaine’s comparison of this principle to Iran’s theocratic regime—a system rooted in false religion, radical ideology that oppresses women, promotes terrorism, and seeks to destroy Israel—has drawn sharp rebukes from Senator Ted Cruz and Bishop Robert Barron, who argue that his stance threatens the very freedoms America was built to protect.
Read More
Kaine’s Misstep: Rejecting a Foundational Truth
Kaine’s comments were in response to Barnes’ assertion that “all men are created equal because our rights come from God, our Creator—not from our laws, not from our governments.” Kaine, a self-described Catholic, rejected this view, stating, “The notion that rights don’t come from laws and don’t come from the government, but come from the Creator—that’s what the Iranian government believes. It’s a theocratic regime that bases its rule on Sharia law and targets Sunnis, Bahá’ís, Jews, Christians, and other religious minorities. So the statement that our rights do not come from our laws or our governments is extremely troubling.”
Kaine’s comparison is deeply flawed. Iran’s theocratic regime operates under a perverse ideology and worship of false gods. Iran’s government has been a U.S.-designated state sponsor of terrorism since 1984, arming groups like Hezbollah, Hamas, and the Houthis to destabilize the Middle East and beyond. Its explicit threats to annihilate Israel, the covenant people of the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, further expose its ideology as one of violence and tyranny, not the God of the Bible revealed in the Person of Jesus Christ our Lord. Equating this regime to the American principle of God-given rights, rooted in natural law and universal equality, fundamentally misrepresents both the Founders’ intent and the stark moral contrast between the two systems. It makes one wonder, what is this man doing in government in America anyway?
The Declaration of Independence, penned by Virginia’s Thomas Jefferson in 1776, unequivocally states, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” This principle asserts that rights are inherent, existing before and beyond the government’s reach. The U.S. Constitution is designed to secure these pre-existing rights, as evidenced by the Ninth Amendment’s acknowledgment of unenumerated rights retained by the people. Kaine’s emphasis on rights deriving from laws or government, citing the Supreme Court’s motto “equal justice under law” and the senatorial oath to defend the Constitution, inverts this foundational truth, raising concerns that Kaine views the state as the ultimate arbiter of freedom—a dangerous precedent that could justify governmental overreach.
Cruz’s Common-Sense Defense
Senator Ted Cruz, a Texas Republican, was visibly shocked by Kaine’s remarks, offering a direct and principled rebuttal. “I just walked into the hearing as he was saying that, and I almost fell out of my chair,” Cruz said. “That ‘radical and dangerous notion’—in his words—is literally the founding principle upon which the United States of America was created. We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed by their Creator—not by government, not by the Democratic National Committee, but by God—with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Cruz’s response, grounded in the Declaration’s text, reaffirmed the common-sense understanding that American liberty depends on rights being inalienable, not subject to government whim. He warned that Kaine’s view risks empowering the state to revoke freedoms at will.
Cruz doubled down, writing, “Our rights don’t come from government or the DNC. They come from God. @timkaine, I suggest the Dems go back and read the words of our Founding Fathers.” His words resonated with those who see Kaine’s stance as a departure from the principles that have defined the nation for over two centuries.
Bishop Barron’s Theological Insight
Catholic Bishop Robert Barron of the Diocese of Winona-Rochester, Minnesota, provided a powerful defense of America’s founding principles in a video on September 4. Addressing Kaine directly, Barron stated, “Virginia, Senator Kaine’s state, gave us Thomas Jefferson, who wrote those famous words in the Declaration of Independence, and James Madison, who was the chief architect of the Constitution. Both of them were absolutely clear that our rights do not come from the government but from God. God help us if we say our rights are coming to us from the government. That gives the government, indeed, God-like power.” Barron’s analysis underscored that the concept of God-given rights is not a theocratic imposition but a safeguard against tyranny, rooted in Enlightenment thought and natural law accessible to all. He emphasized that Iran’s oppressive regime, with its false claim to divine authority, bears no resemblance to the transcendent Creator invoked by the Founders to ensure liberty.
I’d like to respond to a disturbing contention from Senator Tim Kaine, during a recent confirmation hearing. pic.twitter.com/hvaYlQQybi
— Bishop Robert Barron (@BishopBarron) September 4, 2025A Dangerous Misunderstanding
Kaine’s remarks have drawn widespread criticism for misunderstanding the philosophical bedrock of the United States. Virginia’s own Declaration of Rights, authored by George Mason in 1776, declares that “all men are by nature equally free and independent and have certain inherent rights.” By suggesting that rights originate from government, Kaine risks endorsing a framework where freedoms can be arbitrarily granted or withdrawn—a stark contrast to the Founders’ vision. Conservative commentator Matt Walsh called Kaine’s statement “remarkable,” arguing, “He just announced that the core foundational principle of our country, affirmed in the Declaration of Independence, is ‘extremely troubling’ and ‘theocratic.’ He should be immediately removed from office.” The Virginia Republican Party echoed this sentiment, accusing Kaine of aligning with a view that empowers government over individual liberty.
Kaine’s defenders might argue he was highlighting the challenges of defining rights in a diverse society, where religious differences could complicate a universal standard. Yet his comparison to Iran’s theocracy—a regime that serves a false ideology through oppression, terror, and hostility toward God’s covenant people—has overshadowed any such nuance, leaving him open to accusations of betraying America’s core values.
A Call to Reaffirm the Founding
Kaine’s shocking statement reveals the heart of a man deeply confused and serves as a wake-up call for Americans to revisit the principles that define our nation. The Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, born in Kaine’s own Virginia, affirm that rights are endowed by a Creator, not bestowed by government. As Cruz and Barron have articulated, this truth is both common sense and essential to preserving liberty. By equating this principle to Iran’s tyrannical regime, Kaine has not only mischaracterized America’s founding but also ignored the moral chasm between a nation built on freedom and a theocracy built on oppression. The debate challenges citizens and leaders alike to recommit to the self-evident truths that birthed the United States.
